Question

Why do people taste things so differently, and what is a supertaster?

Vault Verified
Curated Intelligence
Definitive Source
Answer

Because taste perception varies genetically, anatomically and by experience — and the differences are large enough that two people eating the same thing can be having substantially different experiences rather than disagreeing about the same one.

The supertaster finding. A proportion of people are unusually sensitive to bitter compounds, identified through their response to PROP and PTC, chemicals related to those in brassicas. Populations divide roughly into non-tasters, tasters and supertasters, with supertasters commonly estimated at around a quarter, varying by population.

What underlies it:

The TAS2R38 gene, which codes a bitter receptor. Different variants produce markedly different sensitivity, and this is one of the clearest single-gene effects on everyday perception.

Fungiform papillae density. Supertasters tend to have more taste papillae on the tongue — the anatomical correlate, countable under magnification.

What supertasters actually experience: stronger bitterness from brassicas, coffee, dark chocolate, grapefruit, olives, tonic water and some beers; greater sensitivity to capsaicin, alcohol burn and fat texture — because these are partly trigeminal sensations that also intensify; and frequently a narrower range of foods enjoyed.

It is not an advantage. Supertasters are not better tasters — they experience more intensity, which can be unpleasant, and the trade-off is real. Some evidence associates the trait with lower vegetable consumption.

The other sources of variation, which matter as much:

Coriander and the OR6A2 gene, where a variant makes the herb taste of soap, since the same aldehydes occur in soap.

Asparagus, where variation exists in both producing the odorous compounds and in being able to smell them.

Smell dominates flavour, and olfactory receptor genes vary enormously between individuals — with substantially more variation than taste genes.

Experience and exposure, which shift preference strongly over time, particularly for bitter and spicy food.

Age, since taste and smell decline gradually from middle age.

Saliva composition, which affects how compounds reach receptors.

The practical implication: disagreements about food are frequently not matters of taste in the metaphorical sense but literally different sensory input.

Related Questions