Does eating seasonally and locally actually matter?
For taste and cost, frequently yes. For environmental impact, far less than people assume — because transport is a small share of most foods' footprint, and the intuition that local always means lower impact is one of the most robustly contradicted beliefs in food.
What the evidence shows about food miles. Transport typically accounts for a small percentage of the total emissions of most foods — commonly under 10%, and frequently far less for the highest-impact products. Production dominates, particularly land use, fertiliser and — decisively — whether the food is animal-derived.
The consequences of that:
What you eat matters far more than where it came from. The difference between food types dwarfs the difference between local and imported versions of the same food, by a wide margin.
Locally grown out of season can be worse. Produce grown in a heated greenhouse in winter frequently has a higher footprint than the same item grown in a suitable climate and shipped — because sea freight is remarkably efficient per kilogram.
Air freight is the genuine exception. It carries emissions orders of magnitude higher than shipping, and applies to a small set of highly perishable items — some berries, asparagus, fresh fish and certain fruits flown rather than shipped. Avoiding air-freighted produce is a meaningful action; avoiding imports generally is not.
Where seasonal and local genuinely deliver:
Flavour and quality, which is the strongest honest argument — produce harvested ripe and sold quickly is measurably better.
Cost, since in-season produce is abundant.
Supporting local economies, which is a legitimate value that should be argued on its own terms rather than dressed as carbon reduction.
Variety and connection to growing, which changes how people cook.
Lower waste in short supply chains, sometimes.
What actually reduces food-related impact most, in order: eating less meat and dairy, particularly beef and lamb; reducing food waste, which is enormous and entirely within household control; and avoiding air-freighted items.