What is the difference between synthetic and mineral engine oil?
Mineral oil is refined directly from crude petroleum. Synthetic oil is engineered — either heavily processed from petroleum stock or built from chemically synthesised base molecules — so that the molecules are uniform in size and shape.
That uniformity is the whole point. Mineral oil contains molecules of many different sizes, along with waxes and impurities that refining does not fully remove. Those irregularities are why it thickens more in cold, breaks down faster under heat, and leaves more deposits.
The practical differences follow:
Cold flow. Synthetic oil stays fluid at much lower temperatures, reaching the top of the engine faster on a cold start — which is when most engine wear occurs.
Heat stability. Synthetic resists oxidation and thermal breakdown far better, which matters in turbocharged engines where oil passes through very hot bearings.
Service interval. Synthetic typically lasts considerably longer, which offsets a good deal of its higher price.
Deposits. Synthetic keeps the engine cleaner, with fewer sludge and varnish deposits over time.
Semi-synthetic is a blend, offering part of the benefit at part of the cost.
The decision is usually made for you. Most cars built in the last twenty years specify a synthetic or semi-synthetic oil, and modern engines with variable valve timing and tight tolerances depend on the specified grade behaving as designed. Use what the manual states.
One persistent myth worth dispatching: switching an older engine to synthetic does not cause leaks. Synthetic oil does not dissolve seals. What can happen is that a high-mileage engine already has hardened seals and existing deposits masking a leak, and a detergent oil cleans those deposits away, revealing it.
High-mileage oils contain seal conditioners for exactly that situation.