What is green finance, and what is a green bond?
Finance directed towards environmentally beneficial activity — and a green bond is its most visible instrument: a normal bond whose proceeds are earmarked for qualifying projects.
How a green bond works. An issuer — a government, bank or company — borrows in the usual way, promising the same repayment and interest as any other bond of the same credit quality. The difference is a commitment about use of proceeds: the money funds renewable energy, efficient buildings, clean transport, water infrastructure or similar, with reporting on where it went.
The crucial and frequently missed point. A green bond is usually backed by the issuer's whole balance sheet, not by the projects. It does not ring-fence risk, and defaulting on the green commitment generally does not trigger a default on the bond itself — enforcement rests on reputation rather than on contract.
Related instruments:
Sustainability-linked bonds, where the interest rate changes if the issuer misses stated targets. This puts a financial penalty behind the promise, and is stronger in principle — with criticism that many targets are unambitious or would have been met anyway.
Transition finance, for high-emitting sectors reducing emissions rather than already-clean activity. Contested, because it directs capital to fossil-dependent industries, and defensible because those are where the emissions are.
Green loans and sustainability-linked loans, the private equivalents.
The additionality question, which is the heart of the criticism. If a company would have built the wind farm anyway, labelling the bond green changes nothing about the world — it relabels existing activity. Demonstrating that finance caused something to happen is genuinely hard, and much reporting does not attempt it.
The other criticisms: inconsistent definitions of what qualifies; limited external verification in some markets; the "greenium" — a slightly lower borrowing cost — being small enough that it barely changes behaviour; and issuers using green bonds while expanding fossil activity elsewhere.
What is improving: official taxonomies defining qualifying activity, mandatory climate-related disclosure in several jurisdictions, and regulatory attention to fund labelling after widespread mislabelling.